Most venue operators focus their commercial lease negotiation on rent, incentives and the rent review mechanism. Demolition clauses and make good obligations often sit further down the document and get less attention. That is a mistake. These two clauses decide who carries the cost when the lease ends early or the site is redeveloped, and in hospitality the numbers involved are rarely small.
A bar fit-out with joinery, exhaust, cool room, floor finishes and services connections can run into six figures. A kitchen upgrade in a restaurant can do the same. If the lease requires you to strip all of that out and return the premises to bare shell, you pay twice: once to build it, once to remove it. When you are running FOH and BOH on tight margins and long hours, a six-figure exit bill landing at the end of a lease can sink an otherwise healthy venue. Deal with these clauses before you sign, not after a landlord serves notice.
Does the Retail Leases Act apply to your venue?
The Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) covers premises used wholly or predominantly for the retail sale or hire of goods or the retail provision of services. A restaurant, cafe or bar open to customers will usually fall inside that definition, though the analysis depends on how the premises are actually used. Some occupancies fall outside the Act. If the Act applies, it overrides lease terms that try to contract out of it. If it does not apply, the lease wording and general contract law govern everything, and the tenant protections below do not apply.
Confirm which regime you are in before you negotiate. It changes the entire risk picture.
How the demolition clause operates
Section 56 of the Act applies where a retail premises lease gives the landlord a right to terminate on the ground of proposed demolition. If your lease contains that right, the Act reads certain terms into it.
- Genuine proposal and notice. The landlord cannot terminate unless it provides details of the proposed demolition sufficient to show a genuine proposal to demolish within a reasonably practicable time, and gives at least six months' written notice of the termination date.
- Early exit for the tenant. Once a valid notice is received, the tenant may terminate earlier on at least seven days' written notice.
- Compensation for fit-out. The landlord is liable for reasonable compensation for the fit-out of the premises to the extent the fit-out was not provided by the landlord. This applies whether or not the demolition actually happens.
- Compensation if demolition does not proceed. The landlord is also liable for damage caused by early termination if the demolition is not carried out, or not carried out within a reasonably practicable time after the termination date. The landlord has a defence on this limb if it can show a genuine proposal existed when notice was given. That defence does not extend to the fit-out compensation.
Two points deserve attention. First, the Act does not prescribe how "reasonable compensation" for fit-out is measured. Whether that means depreciated value, written-down cost or something else is not settled in the text, and Victorian case law on the question is limited. Second, "demolition" is defined broadly. It includes substantial repair, renovation or reconstruction that cannot practicably be done with you in possession. A landlord planning a major refurbishment may be able to use the clause.
If the lease contains no demolition termination right, the landlord has no section 56 route to end the lease early. That is a negotiating point in itself.
Disclosure of demolition and relocation clauses
The Victorian Small Business Commission requires the disclosure statement to address the tenant's fit-out requirements and any relocation or demolition clauses. The landlord must give the disclosure statement and proposed lease no later than 14 days before the lease is entered into. If they arrive later, the lease start date shifts. On renewal, the landlord must provide a disclosure statement at least 21 days before the current lease ends, setting out changes from the previous one.
A false, misleading or materially incomplete disclosure statement can give the tenant termination rights. Read the demolition and fit-out sections of the disclosure statement against the lease itself and raise discrepancies before you sign.
Make good: the clause that outlives the lease
The Act does not set out the scope of make good in specific terms. The VSBC describes make good in general terms as an obligation to return the premises to the condition required by the lease, which might include removing the fit-out, repairing damage beyond fair wear and tear, or returning the premises to their condition at the start of the lease. The precise obligation depends almost entirely on the lease wording.
That is why make good disputes are common and expensive. A clause requiring return "to base building condition" is very different from one requiring return "in good repair, fair wear and tear excepted, with the tenant's fit-out removed and made good". The first can mean removing services, capping penetrations and reinstating floors. The second may leave substantial value in place for the next tenant.
Three practical points for venue operators:
- Pin the starting condition. A condition report and dated photographs of the premises at handover give you a baseline. Without one, arguments about what the premises looked like before your fit-out become a contest of memory.
- Deal with landlord-provided items separately. Section 56 fit-out compensation covers only fit-out the landlord did not provide. If the landlord installed the exhaust canopy or the grease trap, that item sits outside the compensation entitlement and may still need to be made good at your cost.
- Document completion. The VSBC advises tenants to write to the landlord confirming obligations are complete. Do this in writing and keep the record. The security deposit must be returned within 30 days once all obligations are met.
Buying a business means inheriting the make good
The VSBC has confirmed that a tenant who buys a business and takes over an existing lease still carries the make good obligations under that lease. For anyone acquiring a cafe or venue, this belongs in due diligence alongside the fit-out condition and the remaining lease term. A distressed asset purchase can look attractive until the make good liability is costed. Our due diligence for distressed hospitality assets covers this territory.
Negotiating points before you sign
The time to shift risk is before execution. Once the lease is signed, the landlord has little reason to revisit these clauses. The VSBC's guidance on lease negotiation sets out the general areas open to discussion, and the same logic applies here.
- Narrow the demolition right. Ask whether the clause is needed at all, and if so, whether it can be limited to genuine demolition of the building rather than refurbishment. Ensure the section 56 notice and compensation framework is not excluded.
- Define make good by reference to the starting condition. Attach the condition report and photographs as a schedule. Specify what must be removed and what may stay.
- Cap or cash-settle the obligation. Some tenants negotiate a fixed make good payment or a cap on reinstatement cost. Others negotiate that the landlord keeps the fit-out. Both are worth raising.
- Address the fit-out compensation mechanism. Since the Act leaves the measure of reasonable compensation open, agree a method in the lease, for example depreciated written-down value.
- Confirm the disclosure timing. Ensure the disclosure statement and proposed lease arrive at least 14 days before signing, and that they match the lease.
If a dispute does arise, retail leasing matters must be referred to the VSBC before VCAT can hear them. The VSBC offers free preliminary assistance and mediation, and Part 10 of the Act sets out the dispute resolution process. That pathway is slower than a commercial negotiation but usually cheaper than litigation.
None of this guarantees an outcome. The Act sets a floor, not a ceiling, and the lease wording determines most of the exposure. But the difference between a carefully negotiated make good clause and a broad one can be the difference between a manageable exit and a six-figure bill at the worst possible time.
This information is general in nature. Contact us for advice specific to your venue.